Halloween Study Crowns Insidious the Scariest Horror Movie

Searches for Hocus Pocus 2 have seen a 5,000 percent increase, according to Google Trends, which goes to show people are already in the mood to be spooked!

To inspire a spooky atmosphere, the experts at FindMyCasino.com decided to find out the scariest horror movies, by utilising a seed list of the 100 popular all-time best horrors and collecting the number of jump scares for each.

Here are the top 20 scariest horror movies, ranked 

Rank

Horror Movie

Release Year

Number of Jump Scares

1

Insidious

2010

24

2=

It

2017

23

2=

Drag Me to Hell

2009

23

2=

Friday the 13th

2009

23

5

The Evil Dead

1981

22

6

Evil Dead

2013

20

7

Scream

1996

19

8

Scream 4

2011

18

9=

Sinister

2012

17

9=

Don't Breathe

2016

17

11=

X

2022

16

11=

The Descent

2005

16

11=

The Strangers

2008

16

11=

Candyman

1992

16

15=

A Quiet Place Part II

2020

15

15=

Martyrs

2008

15

15=

The Ritual

2017

15

15=

Underwater

2020

15

19=

A Quiet Place

2018

14

19=

Halloween

2018

14

Please find the complete data sheet with all 100 horror movies ranked in this folder.

First place for the scariest horror movie goes to Insidious (2010) with a whopping 24 jump scares throughout its 103 minutes runtime. It also received a perfect jump scare rating of five stars. This is the first movie in the Insidious franchise and is followed by Insidious: Chapter 2, Insidious: Chapter 3 and Insidious: The Last Key.

With a total of 23 jump scares, second place is shared by It (2017), Drag Me to Hell (2009) and Friday the 13th (2009). It, which is based on a Stephen King novel, had the lowest jump scare percentage of the three—17 percent, while the other two movies had 23 percent and 24 percent respectively. In terms of jump scare rating, Drag Me to Hell had the highest—4.5 stars.

Following closely behind, The Evil Dead (1981) places fifth in the study, having generated 22 jump scares. The horror movie’s duration is 99 minutes and its jump scare rating is four stars. Interestingly, the movie, along with the three other horrors in the Evil Dead series following it, was written by the same person as Drag Me to Hell—Sam Raimi. 

Lilly Sabir, a psychologist at Oxford Spires Practice, comments on what being scared does to a person’s psyche and why people like watching horror movies, and therefore, feeling scared: “This is to do with human beings feeling the need to be stimulated. Fear responses can produce anxiety-like symptoms but we are prepared for them when watching a horror movie so the effect is stimulation within our control. We produce chemical responses in the body and mind, and that stimulation process can lead to heightened arousal. If you like, we sometimes refer to it as getting a bit of a kick from our environmental stimuli, getting spooked and quite literally feeling ‘alive’.”

Methodology

  1. FindMyCasino.com sought to find out the scariest horror movies based on jump scares.

  2. A comprehensive seed list of 100 popular all-time best horror movies was extracted from IMDb.

  3. Following this, each movie was manually inputted into Where’s the Jump? (a website, which tracks the number of jump scares throughout a horror movie) and the number of jump scares, the jump scare rating (out of five), along with the movies’ runtime (min) were recorded. Additionally, the jump scare percentage and jump scares per minute were calculated for each movie.

  4. The movies were then ranked based on the amount of jump scares they had generated, so that the scariest horror movie could be determined.

  5. All data was collected on 29 September 2022 and is subject to change.